Nestled among Pennsylvania's rolling hills is Bird-in-Hand, a tiny village where Amish, Mennonites, and Englishers live side by side. It's here where the close-knit Classen sisters reunite after inheriting their family home-- a beautiful Victorian farmhouse-- with hopes of reopening their grandmother's incredibly popular gift and thrift store, Secondhand Blessings, housed in the centuries-old barn next to the house. Soon life in this quiet community is bursting with excitement and unexplained mysteries. Little do the sisters know as they gather up flea-market finds, handmade quilts, and baked goods from their own kitchen that they're filling the nooks and crannies of their rustic store with a host of mysteries and surprises! But the sisters end up with more than they bargained for when Anita Smucker, who donated dozens of items from her wealthy parents' estate, accuses them of stealing a valuable family heirloom. Anita isn't certain what it is and the sisters don't know if they've sold it or if it's still sitting on their shelves. As the sisters work to solve the mystery, what they discover goes way beyond anything they ever expected. Suddenly, the lives of the three Classen sisters are changed forever.